I grabbed three of these, on sale. Clove, licorice (I keep calling it that but it's Black Jack haha) and the dotty one. They are cute, very lightweight but wayyy too short. I mean, I know I have some serious buns but they weren't even long enough for me to feel comfortable wearing leggings or someth...ing under, they came to right below my buns! (Yes, you read that right, I said buns) Also, I don't think I saw a review mentioning but the waistbands are done in a really weird way. I'm including pictures... each one was folded over a length of elastic and like sewn only in four places? So it flips around while it's being warn and stuff. I'd never seen anything like that. So I wouldn't suggest them to a friend because of the waistband, the length will probably be apparent enough to most folks though. If they were made better (I'm sorry!) I'd suggest them to folks who they might work on in a more... functional way?