BUY THIS - it's super cute, great quality, runs a little short great for the wide leg pants we're all wearing. I'm 5-8 and with regular straight pants I would probably order the Tall. Again, love the length as-is and I'm tall. ON has great tall selections :) To the decision makers at ON, thank you... for not using vanity sizing for this top - over the years we are now embracing crazy large huge-to-sizing. So now if a top runs the way it SHOULD, people are outraged and comparing it to "child size"??? I am an actual size 12-14 bottom (5-8, 170 pounds -I now wear a small tall in your linen pants and a 8-10 for others. I LOVE them, but I am not NOT not a size small, as much as I would love to be. Retailers do us no favors by lying to us when sizing apparel - to be a healthy not obese/overweight, I should lose 10-20 pounds. I own my weight gain, the solution is diet/excercise and don't fault anyone for trying medications if educated as to the risks. Women of all ages deserve and should appreciate when sizes are TRUTHFUL - we aren't a number, but the sizes should matter. Stop trying to makes us feel better by making SMALLS/MEDIUMS fit like the old Large/XL sizing. Customers may not like it at first but it gets us back to reality and what sizing used to be... don't contribute to the obesity epidemic. thank you!!