I've now bought this cardigan in both black and "wishbone" (cream). Only drawback for me is the price point, which feels kinda steep unless you can snag it on sale or use super cash toward it. My favorite feature is how the sleeves balloon out to the wristband, which makes the cardi wearable over ...pretty much any style or sleeve-length of top. So many cardigans out there have snug-fitting sleeves, which makes it impossible to wear flowy long-sleeve or half-sleeve blouses under them without the fabric bunching up! Problem solved with the design of this cardi. I usually wear a M in ON tops (I'm about 5'6, 140 lbs, 36C) and I tried on both the M and L since some reviewers said they sized up for a slouchier fit. On me, the L looked sloppy, especially from behind. I find the M roomy enough to feel comfortable but still look tailored, and it drapes equally well whether hanging open or buttoned up. True, the button holes are on the snug side but with some patience, you can get it unbuttoned--and I'd rather button holes be too snug than too loose. I could see the weave of the knit being snag-prone (be careful around pets with claws), but all in all, I look forward to wearing both colors as the seasons transition, or even on a cool summer night. Can't attest yet to how they hold up in the wash, but I plan to wash in cold water and line dry.