I bought these exact extra high- waisted Rockstar 360° jeans a few years ago, and they were my favorite jeans ever. I wore them until they started getting too faded to look nice, and so worn that they began to get tiny rips in them. I finally decided it was time to buy new ones. Bought these which ...are supposed to be the exact ones I originally purchased, and I bought them in the black wash and also in the faded black wash. Both pairs had what I can only describe as an extra amount of fabric in the crotch and lower belly area, which formed a sort of pooch, making it look like my lower stomach pooched out. Not flattering at all. Also, both washes fit different. While both had that extra weird pooch thing going on, with the black wash pair it was was even worse than the faded black wash. I washed and dried them to see if it might help to tighten up that area but it didn't help, so I returned them. I thought I might be crazy because it didn't make sense how the EXACT same jeans I had bought years before were so different fitting this time around. But luckily I found a thread on Reddit with others also sharing stories of how the quality, size and fit of Old Navy pants has become commonly inconsistent over time. Hopefully someday they'll work on fixing this lack of consistency. It's pretty much impossible to find jeans with such a high waist fit nowadays, but I'll keep on looking elsewhere from now on.